Hallux Rigidus

Do you suffer from pain in the metatarsophalangeal joint that restricts your movement? Do you have difficulty rolling your foot or find it difficult to find shoes that fit? Then hallux rigidus could be the cause of your symptoms.

Here you will find comprehensive information about this condition and the treatment options at our specialist centre.

Symptoms: When the big toe hurts and becomes stiff

Hallux rigidus, also known as osteoarthritis of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe, manifests itself through various symptoms. Typical symptoms are

  • Pain in the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe. This occurs particularly when rolling the foot, for example when walking or running uphill, when the big toe is pushed upwards as far as possible. Pain under the ball of the big toe, especially after sporting activity, is also possible.
  • Restricted movement of the big toe. It is particularly difficult to extend the toe upwards (dorsiflexion). In the advanced stage, mobility may be restricted in all directions. The early stage with limited mobility is also known as hallux limitus.
  • Swelling and inflammation of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe. In the case of activated osteoarthritis, the joint may be painfully swollen and reddened.
  • Formation of bone spurs (osteophytes). These can develop above the joint and interfere with wearing shoes. These bony growths can often be felt around the joint in the shape of a ring.
  • Change in the gait pattern. Those affected often try to relieve the painful metatarsophalangeal joint and increasingly roll over the outer edge of the foot. This can lead to pain in other toes, the foot, lower leg, knee, hip and back.
  • Difficulties in choosing shoes. The stiffening and bone spurs make it increasingly difficult to find suitable and comfortable shoes.
  • Joint noises (crepitation) can occur in later stages.

Causes: How does hallux rigidus develop?

There are many causes for the development of hallux rigidus. It is often a combination of different factors. Possible causes and risk factors include

  • Degenerative wear and tear (osteoarthritis) of the articular cartilage in the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe. This can develop over time as a result of the high load on the joint.
  • Incorrect loading and overloading through sport or a relative excess length of the first metatarsal bone, which leads to excessive pressure in the metatarsophalangeal joint.
  • Accidents (trauma), which can lead to damage to the joint cartilage. This is often the cause of unilateral hallux rigidus.
  • Genetic predisposition (familial tendency). In these cases, hallux rigidus often occurs on both sides.
  • Severely pronounced deformities of the feet, such as hallux valgus or a flattening of the longitudinal arch of the foot (pronation). A misaligned first toe ray (metatarsus elevatus) can also overload the joint.
  • Inflammatory joint diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis or gout. Metabolic disorders such as diabetes can also play a role.
  • In some cases, hallux rigidus can also occur as a result of hallux valgus surgery.

Diagnosis: How we diagnose hallux rigidus

Die Diagnose Hallux rigidus wird in unserer Fachzentrum sorgfältig und umfassend gestellt. Hierbei kommen verschiedene Schritte zum Einsatz:

Clinical examination

In a personal consultation, we will ask you about your complaints and their progression. This is followed by a thorough physical examination of the foot. We pay attention to:

  • Mobility of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe, in particular the restriction of upward extension. The mobility is compared with the healthy opposite side.
  • Pain points and their localisation, especially when pressure is applied to the upper part of the joint.
  • Palpable bone spurs (osteophytes) around the joint.
  • Changes in the gait pattern.
  • Condition of the cartilage using special tests such as the "grinding test", in which pain can be triggered by a grinding movement if there is a central cartilage defect.

 

X-ray image

An X-ray of the foot under load usually confirms the diagnosis. We can recognise the following changes on the X-ray:

  • Narrowing of the joint space due to cartilage degradation.
  • Presence of osteophytes (bone spurs) at the edges of the joint.
  • Signs of overload on the bone close to the joint in the form of sclerosis lines (hardening of the bone) and cysts (fluid inclusions).

In some cases, further imaging procedures such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may be useful to assess the condition of the cartilage and soft tissue more precisely.

The radiological findings help us to classify the severity of hallux rigidus into different stages (I-IV). This categorisation is important for choosing the appropriate treatment.

Conservative treatments (without surgery)

In the early stages of hallux rigidus or when there is little discomfort, conservative treatment methods can often achieve significant relief of symptoms.

The aim is to reduce pain, improve mobility and slow down the progression of osteoarthritis.

Conservative measures include

Injection therapy

  • Cortisone infiltrations into the joint can have a good effect on inflammation and pain in the short to medium term. However, they are not recommended as long-term therapy.
  • Hyaluronic acid injections into the joint can alleviate both stress and rest pain in some patients and contribute to cartilage nutrition. However, the effect may diminish as cartilage wear progresses.
  • Autologous blood therapy can also be used in the early stages to relieve pain and improve mobility.

Drug therapy

  • Anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) in tablet form can reduce pain and inflammation.
  • Painkillers can be taken if necessary.

Physiotherapy

Mobilisation exercises involving traction on the toe can help to stretch the joint capsule and make the joint more flexible. Stretching exercises of the calf muscles can also be useful for athletes with hallux rigidus.

Manual therapy and strengthening exercises can also be part of the treatment.

Modification of the footwear

This plays a decisive role. Recommended:

  • Shoes with stiff soles and roll-off aids to relieve the metatarsophalangeal joint when walking and avoid excessive painful movements. A cradle sole can also be helpful.
  • Sufficient space in the shoe, especially in the toe area, to avoid pressure points on the bone attachments.
  • If necessary, the manufacture or modification of orthopaedic shoes.

 

Insole supply

Special insoles, especially with a bunion roller or a stiffener under the big toe, can relieve the metatarsophalangeal joint and reduce the strain. Supporting the longitudinal arch of the foot can also be useful.

Adaptation of lifestyle

Avoid activities that cause pain and, if necessary, reduce weight to relieve the pressure on the feet.

Surgical treatments - when conservative measures are no longer sufficient

If the level of suffering remains high despite conservative measures having been exhausted or the osteoarthritis is already very advanced, surgery may be considered.

The choice of surgical procedure depends on the stage of osteoarthritis and the individual needs of the patient.

We offer the entire spectrum of stage-appropriate surgical treatment.

Joint-preserving operations (cheilectomy)

Cheilectomy can help with mild to moderate osteoarthritis (grade I and II) and circumscribed pressure symptoms caused by bone spurs.

In this procedure, the troublesome bone attachments (osteophytes) around the joint are removed and the part of the joint with the worn cartilage layer is also removed.

The aim is to improve mobility and reduce pain. In some cases, this procedure can be minimally invasive. Cheilectomy is often combined with an osteotomy (bone rearrangement) of the big toe (Moberg osteotomy) to further improve upward mobility.

If the first ray is too long, a shortening osteotomy can also be performed (Youngswick osteotomy or oblique osteotomy).

The chances of success after a cheilectomy are generally good, with more than 80% of patients being satisfied or very satisfied.

Stiffening operation (arthrodesis of the metatarsophalangeal joint)

In advanced osteoarthritis (grade III and IV), fusion of the metatarsophalangeal joint is the most reliable method of permanently eliminating pain in the joint.

The residual cartilage is removed and the neighbouring bones are fused together to create a pain-free but immobile joint.

Functional restrictions when walking are usually minimal. Even the ability to play sports is usually retained. The only restrictions are in the choice of shoes, although heels up to approx. 3 cm high can usually still be worn.

The chances of success after arthrodesis are very high. Even with a stiffened big toe joint, patients can usually walk well and resume many types of sport.

Joint replacement (endoprosthesis of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the big toe)

In individual, selected cases, an artificial joint can also be used as an alternative to fusion, especially in advanced stages of osteoarthritis with good residual mobility, if there are individual reasons against arthrodesis.

There are various types of prostheses, such as elastic surface replacement prostheses made of cartilage-like plastic.

However, due to higher complication rates, joint replacement is only considered in exceptional cases.

We attach great importance to state-of-the-art surgical techniques and implants, taking into account the biomechanics of the entire foot.

Aftercare - your path to recovery

After the operation, careful aftercare is crucial for optimal healing. The aftercare depends on the type of procedure:

After cheilectomy and joint-preserving surgery

  • Elevation of the foot for the first two weeks to allow the wound to heal.
  • Mobilisation of the metatarsophalangeal joint in a therapeutic shoe until the wound has healed.
  • Ideally, start physiotherapy after two weeks to train mobility.
  • Gradual change to comfortable everyday shoes (preferably running or hiking shoes) may be possible after 2 weeks.

After arthrodesis (fusion surgery)

  • Inpatient stay of two to three days.
  • Elevation of the foot for the first two weeks to improve wound healing.
  • Mobilisation in physiotherapy takes place in a therapeutic shoe that protects the arthrodesis. Partial weight-bearing may be necessary at first.
  • After six weeks, a follow-up check is carried out with a clinical examination and X-ray.
  • Depending on the progress of healing, the foot must continue to be immobilised on a hard sole.
  • After 6 weeks, you can switch to a comfortable everyday shoe with a stiffer sole and ideally a roll-off support.

General instructions for aftercare

  • In the first few weeks after the operation, the foot should be protected and weight-bearing should be increased slowly.
  • Crutches can be provided for support.
  • It is normal for the foot to swell, which will slowly subside over several months (approx. 1 month per decade of life). It may therefore be necessary to wear oversized replacement shoes for the first few months.
  • Depending on the occupation and level of activity, it can take up to 3 months before most professional and everyday activities can be fully resumed. It usually takes around 1 year for the swelling to completely subside and normalise (final result).

Book a consultation appointment

Dr Andreas L. Oberholzer is an experienced FMH specialist in orthopaedics and trauma surgery.

We guarantee rapid, expert clarification and advice as well as treatment using the most modern methods.

Book your appointment directly online here or call us on +41 44 388 16 16. You are also welcome to come to us for a second opinion.

General Swiss insurance (basic health insurance) is sufficient for a consultation at our specialist centre.

PD Dr Andreas L. Oberholzer

PD Dr Andreas L. Oberholzer

FMH specialist in orthopaedics and trauma surgery. Areas of specialisation: Knee, hip and foot surgery.

This website uses functional and performance cookies. Our privacy policy contains, among other things, all information on the purposes of use and data transfers. Important to note: Your use of the website constitutes full consent to the use of cookies and the privacy policy.

This website uses functional and performance cookies. Our privacy policy contains, among other things, all information on the purposes of use and data transfers. Important to note: Your use of the website constitutes full consent to the use of cookies and the privacy policy.

Ihre Cookie-Einstellungen wurden gespeichert